Medieval Collectibles Reviews
Medieval Collectibles has an overall rating of 4.2 based on 75 reviews. Customer feedback on Medieval Collectibles is mixed: Medieval Collectibles reviewers highlight positive aspects like wide variety of products, good quality items, helpful customer service, competitive pricing, which strongly appeal to medieval enthusiasts, reenactors, collectors, costume designers. However, Medieval Collectibles is often criticized for its slow shipping times, occasional stock issues, limited international shipping options, higher prices on some items.
75 reviews
5 Stars
12
4 Stars
8
3 Stars
4
2 Stars
2
1 Star
0
How would you rate Medieval Collectibles?
All Medieval Collectibles Reviews (75)
micheal_Walter97
May 23, 2026
"Quick Help and No Guesswork"
They helped me get my order sorted out quickly, which I really appreciated. I’m usually a bit cautious when something goes wrong with an order because I don’t want it turning into a bigger hassle, but they handled it smoothly and kept things simple
0
Reply
krista_William77
May 21, 2026
"My order showed up with one piece damaged…"
My order showed up with one piece damaged, which was... kind of frustrating at first. I sent a couple of photos to customer service, and they got back to me quickly. They sent out a replacement without making it a big hassle, and it arrived in good shape. Stuff happens during shipping, so I’m giving 5 stars for how well they handled it
0
Reply
treva1982
May 19, 2026
"Packed really well"
My order showed up in great shape. Box was solid. Lots of padding inside. Nothing sliding around. I was a little worried it might get damaged, but nope. Opened it up and everything looked fine. Happy with the packaging
0
Reply
Julie_shreffler78
May 15, 2026
"Smooth order, solid tracking"
Ordered from Medieval Collectibles and the tracking was actually useful. I could see when it shipped and where it was, which helps because I get impatient with packages. It showed up about when expected, no weird delays or missing info, and the box was fine. Easy order overall. I’d buy from them again.
0
Reply
Eduardo_miller79
May 15, 2026
"It looks nice and works fine for…"
It looks nice and works fine for the most part, but I do wish it felt a bit more durable. Overall, it’s okay, just not sure how well it’ll hold up long term.
0
Reply
hello_richard381
May 13, 2026
"Pretty good prices overall"
I grabbed a few things it felt worth it. The prices were good for what you get, and it just made sense.
0
Reply
Evelyn.rowe
May 12, 2026
"Good sale prices and a smooth checkout"
I ordered from Medieval Collectibles during a sale and used a discount code at checkout, and it actually worked without any hassle. I know a lot of us worry about promo codes not applying right or some hidden catch popping up, but everything was straightforward. The prices were better than I expected too, especially on a couple of costume pieces I’d been watching for a while. Shipping wasn’t lightning fast, but it was reasonable. The only reason I’m not giving 5 stars is that one item looked a little different from the photo. Still, I’m happy overall and would definitely order again if they’re running another sale.
0
Reply
dana-Roberts
May 09, 2026
"Kind of frustrating for a preorder"
I’m usually fine waiting on preorder items, but this experience was annoying. My order just sat on backorder, and I felt like I had to keep checking in myself to figure out what was going on. Customer service did respond, but the answers were vague and didn’t really help much. It wasn’t a total disaster, but the lack of clear updates definitely left a bad impression...
0
Reply
doris2001
May 07, 2026
"Great medieval fair look"
I was impressed with the designs. They don’t have that cheap costume-shop feel at all. My tunic and belt actually looked like they belonged at a medieval fair, and even my brother said they looked legit. Shipping was smooth too. I’d definitely buy from them again.
0
Reply
lillian-Tubbs
May 05, 2026
"I ordered a couple of items and…"
I ordered a couple of items and the website itself was easy to use. I noticed the checkout buttons and confirmation page were clear, which I always appreciate because I tend to double-check every little thing. The only part that bugged me was the processing time. It took a few days before I got any kind of update, and I kept checking my email wondering if the order was actually moving along. Once it finally shipped, everything was fine, but it just felt like it sat in that in-between stage a bit too long. Overall, not a bad experience, just could be quicker with updates before shipping...
0
Reply
hello_diana885
April 28, 2026
"Quick and helpful response"
So... I emailed Medieval Collectibles with a question about sizing and figured I’d be waiting a day or two. They got back to me within just a few hours, which was a nice surprise. The answer was clear and helped me place my order without having to guess. Always appreciate when a shop actually responds quickly.
0
Reply
Howard_wilson91
April 17, 2026
"Fast shipping, but still a little disappointing"
The shipping was actually really fast and it showed up before the weekend, which I appreciated. I just wish the overall experience had been a bit better, because I was still left feeling kind of disappointed.
0
Reply
JuliaHickey_72
April 13, 2026
"Checkout was easy"
I ordered from medievalcollectibles.com and it was straightforward. Found what I wanted, tossed it in the cart, and checkout went through without any issues. The shipping choices were easy enough to understand, and payment worked fine. I did have to go back and double-check a couple pages because it wasn’t totally clear for a second, but overall it was an easy experience
0
Reply
ShaunDavis_16
March 26, 2026
"Pretty easy site to use, right?"
I actually had a good experience browsing Medieval Collectibles. The menu made sense to me, and I was able to find swords, costumes, and armor without feeling like I was clicking around forever. The search worked fine too, which makes a big difference, doesn’t it? Checkout seemed clear and straightforward, so I didn’t run into any issues there either. Overall, it felt like a simple, easy-to-use site.
0
Reply
RoyWilliams_78
March 20, 2026
"As someone who likes having plenty of…"
As someone who likes having plenty of options to choose from, I was happy with the variety here. I actually found a few things I’d been looking for, so overall it was a good experience
0
Reply
kathleenpercy3885
March 01, 2026
"I ordered a tunic and a…"
I ordered a tunic and a pair of boots from medievalcollectibles. The tunic fit pretty much like the size chart said, so that was fine, but the boots were definitely smaller than expected. I ended up having to exchange them, which felt like wasted time and energy for something that should’ve been straightforward. The quality was good overall, I just wish the sizing was more consistent between items. Not a bad experience, but definitely double-check before you order
0
Reply
chris_Hottle92
February 18, 2026
"I had to make an exchange it was…"
I had to make an exchange it was way easier than I expected. The process was quick and stress-free, and I felt good about getting it sorted without any hassle. Small win for the day!
0
Reply
marcos_Thompson96
February 15, 2026
"I walked in expecting the usual disappointment, but…"
I walked in expecting the usual disappointment, but nope — they had everything available. It felt like a tiny shopping miracle.
0
Reply
EleanorIrby
January 18, 2026
"From a distance it looked okay, but…"
From a distance it looked okay, but once I got closer, the craftsmanship felt rough. The edges weren’t very clean and a few parts looked kind of cheap. I also felt a little dismissed when I brought it up, like my concerns weren’t really taken seriously. It’s not terrible, but for the price, I expected better.
0
Reply
annie.Jones
January 15, 2026
"Everything matched what I ordered, so no complaints…"
Everything matched what I ordered, so no complaints here. I checked it over for a minute or two and it all looked right, about as straightforward as it gets.
0
Reply
Have a question about Medieval Collectibles?
Log in to ask your Medieval Collectibles question!
Customer Reviews
Ask a Question
